On Chang Chienas Change from a Constitutional Monarchist to a Republican - Political Thought with Flexibility as the Underlying Reason
Keywords:
political thought, political flexibility, constitutional monarchy, republic, north-south negotiation
Abstract
Chang Chien was born on July 1st in 1853 in Haimen Kiangsu and died on August 24th in 1926 in Nant'ung Kiangsu. In spite of his extraordinary enthusiasm in the promotion of a constitutional monarchy, Chang Chien changed from a constitutional monarchist to a republican within less than one month after the 1911 Revolution. Why did he change? This is a significant topic for discussion. So far lots of scholars have done research on this topic; however, the answers to this question have not been completely discovered yet. My finding in this paper contends that though reasons leading to Chang Chien's change were complicated, the underlying reason could be attributed to his political thought with flexibility that industry, education and self-government were able to be achieved under whether a constitutional monarchy or a republic to save China. It would be unfair to attribute Chang Chien's change only to his personal ambition to maintain his property, his prestige, or to attain political power. Essentially, it was also due to his pragmatic attitude and his political thought with flexibility which allow him to work out industry, education, and self-government for China whether under a constitutional monarchy or, a republic.
Downloads
- Article PDF
- TEI XML Kaleidoscope (download in zip)* (Beta by AI)
- Lens* NISO JATS XML (Beta by AI)
- HTML Kaleidoscope* (Beta by AI)
- DBK XML Kaleidoscope (download in zip)* (Beta by AI)
- LaTeX pdf Kaleidoscope* (Beta by AI)
- EPUB Kaleidoscope* (Beta by AI)
- MD Kaleidoscope* (Beta by AI)
- FO Kaleidoscope* (Beta by AI)
- BIB Kaleidoscope* (Beta by AI)
- LaTeX Kaleidoscope* (Beta by AI)
How to Cite
References
Chien Chang (1986) Liu-his-ts'ao-t'ang Hih-chi.
Chang (2007) Chang Chien yu Chin-tai Chung-kuo She-hui--Ti ssu-chieh Chang Chien Kuo-chi Hsuehshu Yen-t'ao-hui Lun-wen-chi (Chang Chien and Chinese Society.
Chien Chang, Center (1994) Chang Chien Ch'uan-chi (The Complete Work of Chang Chien).
Hsiao-Jo Chang (1930) Nant'ung Chang Chi-chih Hsien-sheng Chuan-chi.
Hsiao-Jo Chang (1983) Chang-chi-tzu Chiulu (The Nine Records of Chang Chien).
Hsu-Wu ; Chang (2004) Unknown Title.
K Chang, 'ai-Yuan (1963) Discussion on Chang Chien's Contradictory Character. 3, 87-104.
K Chang, 'ai-Yuan (1986) K'ai-to-che te tsu-chi : Chang Chien Chuan-kao (The Footprints of A Trailblazer: A Draft Biography of Chang Chien.
I Chang, Chuang-Chun Liu, Yu-Ting Chang Chien (2000) Strategies for Optimizing the Efficacy of Pop-Up Advertisements in Mobile Commerce Applications.
K Chang, 'ai-Yuan & T'ung T'ian (2002) Chang Chien yu Chin-tai She-hui (Chang Chien and Modern Society.
K Chang, 'ai-Yuan & T'ung T'ian (2011) Hsin-hai Keming Shih-ch'I te Chang Chien yu Chin-tai She-hui (Chang Chien and Modern Society During the Period of 1911 Revolution).
P Chang, 'eng-Yuan (1969) Li-hsien Pai yu Hsin-hai Ke-ming (The Constitutionalists and the 1911 Revolution).
P Chang, 'eng-Yuan (1983) Tsai-lun Li-hsien Pai yu Hsin-hai Ke-ming" (Again on the Constitutionalists and the 1911 Revolution). 187-200.
Yu-Fa Chang (1988) Chung-kuo Hsien-tai-shih (The Contemporary History of China).
Ch'ai, Teh-Keng (1957) Hsin-hai Koming (The 1911 Revolution). 8.
Ch Chin (2003) Chang Chien Yen-chiu Lun-kao.
Hsin-Kuo Chou (2004) Chung-kuo Chin-tai-hua Hsien-ch'u:Chuang-yuan Shi-yeh-chia Chang Chien (A Pioneer for China's Modernization :Chang Chien.
Yi-Chieh ; Hou, Chang Chien Yu Hsin (1911) -hai Koming-Chien Po Chung-chung O-ch'uan, Huan lishih I Chen-shih. 192-217.
Lun Hsu (1962) Chang Chien tsai Hsin-hai Keming chung te Cheng-chih Huo-tung. 408-425.
Jerome Ch, ' En (1983) Chang Chien tsai hsin-hai ch'ien-hsi Cheng-chih Ssi-hsiang te Chuan-pien" (The Change of Chang Chien's Political Thought in the Eve of the 1911 Revolution). 2285-2307.
Shih-Yueh Li (1962) Chang Chien yu Li-hsien-p'a (Chang Chien and the Constitutionalists.
Hou-Sheng Liu (1958) Biography of Chang Chien.
Hou-Sheng Liu (1963) Chang Chien yu Hsin-hai Ke-ming" (Chang Chien and the 1911 Revolution). 6, 261-265.
Yao-Tung Lu (1980) Hsin-hai Ke-ming ch'ien-hou Chang Chien te Chuan-pien" (Chang Chien's Change before and after the 1911 Revolution). 687-700.
Yun-Lung Sheng (1971) Chang Chien and Ch'en Teh-ch'uan tui Hsin-hai K'ai-kuo Ch'en-hou chih Ying-hsiang" (Chang Chien and Ch'en Teh-ch'uan's Impact on China around 1911 Revolution). 2, 271-295.
Shun-Chih Sun (1997) Chang Chien te Cheng-chih Ssu-hsiang" (The Political Thought of Chang Chien) Jen-wen chi She-hui K'o-hsueh Ch'i-k'an. 9(3), 115-144.
Shun-Chih Sun (2001) Chang Chien tsai Hsin-haiko-ming hou yu Chun-hsien chuan wei Kung-ho chih Yen-chiu" (Chang Chien's Conversion from A Constitutional Monarchist to A Republican after the 1911 Revolution). 5(1), 99-115.
Sung, Hsi-Shang (1963) The Career of Chang Chien.
Fu-Hui Ta (1970) Chang Chien Tasi Ch'ing-mo Lihsien Yun-tung Chung te Ti-wei" (Chang Chien's Position in the Constitutional Movement of the Late Ching Period). 1, 27-42.
Chih-Ch ; Ts'ui (2010) yu Haimen : Tsao-ch'i Hsien-tai-hua Ssu-hsiang yu Shih-Chien (Chang Chien and Haimen : The Thoughts and Practice in the Early Period of Modernization ).
Wang Tun-Ch (2005) Ch'uan-t'ung yu Ch'ienchan: Chang Chien Ching-chi Ssu-hsiang Yen-chiu (Tradition and Prospect: A Research on Chang Chien's Economic Thought).
Wang Wei (2004) The Last Imperial Civil Service Examination Champion.
Wu Yi-Yeh (1993) Chang Chien yu Nant'ung Chintai-hua Mo-shih" (Chang Chien and Nant'ung's Model of Modernization). 37-57.
Yu-Chang Wu (1961) Hsin-hai ko-ming (The 1911 Revolution).
(1987) Chang Chien Ts'un-kao (Extant Writings of Chang Chien).
Yen (2006) Wei-ta te Shi-pai Yinghsiung: Chang Chien yu Nant'ung Ch'u-yu tsao-ch'i Hsien-tai-hua Yen-chiu (A Great and Failed Hero: Chang Chien and Nant'ung's Early Modernization).
Hsueh-His ; Yen, Chang Chien Yu (1911) Hsin-hai Ke-ming : yu Li-hsien chuan hsiang Kung-ho te Ssuhsiang Chi-ch'u" (Chang Chien and the. 233-250.
Yu, Ho-P'ing (2004) Chang Chien: Chung-kuo tsao-ch'i Hsien-tai-hua te Ch'ian-ch'u (Chang Chien: A Pioneer for China's Early Modernization) Ch'ang Ch.
Keishu Onodera, Masakiyo Ishikawa, Manami Homura, Keita Takahashi, Koji Hoshino, Yuji Morimoto (1985) Factors related to the prognosis of hyperbaric oxygen therapy for postoperative paralytic ileus. 52(2), 93-99.
Austin Ranney (2001) Governing: An Introduction to Political Science.
P Chang, 'eng-Yuan (1968) The Constitutionalists. 143-183.
Ichiko Chuzo (1968) The Chinese Gentry, An Hypothesis. 297-313.
Elisabeth Koll (2003) From Cotton Mill to Business Empire: The Emergence of Regional Enterprises in Modern China.
Jerome Ch, ' En (1972) Yuan Shih-k'ai.
Louis Sigel (1979) Fitzgerald, Charles Patrick, (5 March 1902-13 April 1992), Professor of Far Eastern History, Australian National University, 1953-67, then Emeritus; Visiting Fellow, Department of International Relations, Australian National University, 1968-69. 19, 111-143.
Marie-Claire Bergere (1968) The Role of the Bourgeoisie. 229-295.
G Michael, Roskin (2008) Political Science, an Introduction.
Peter Zarrow (2006) Qin Shao, Culturing Modernity: The Nantong Model, 1890-1930. 51, 187-196.
Qin Shao (2004) Culturing Modernity: The Nantong Model, 1890-1930.
C Samuel, Chu (1965) Reformer in Modern China: Chang Chien, 1853-1926.
Shun-Chih Sun (1853) Political Thought and Action.
Shun-Chih Sun (1995) The Political Thought of Chang Chien 1853-1926. 7, 85-148.
Shun-Chih Sun (2009) Chang Chien's Ideas and Activities on Constitutional Monarchy. 5(3), 57-72.
Shun-Chih Sun (2010) Chang Chien's Role in the North-South Negotiation 1911-1912. 14, 67-88.
Ssu-Yu Teng, Jeremy Ingalls (1956) The Political History of China, 1840-1928. By Li Chien-Nung. Translated and Edited by Ssu-Yu Teng and Jeremy Ingalls. (Princeton, Toronto, London, New York: D. Van Nostrand Company, Inc.1956. Pp. xii, 545. $7.50.). 51(3), 864-864.
King-Kong Wong (1957) A case study of Hong Kong--Mainland China joint venture.
Published
2013-09-18
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2013 Authors and Global Journals Private Limited

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.