The Creation of Social Welfare Policies: Comparative Analysis between German and Brazilian Experiences

Lara Lucia Da

Authors

Lara Lucia Da

Keywords:

Brazilian social welfare, German social state, historical evolution, comparative analysis

Abstract

The aim of the study was to compare the Brazilian and German social welfare systems, highlighting their similarities and differences and answering the question: have Brazilian social welfare policies moved closer to or farther away from the parent model throughout their historical evolution? The methodology selected for the present study was comparative, with a historical approach. Similarities and differences between the Brazilian social welfare system and Bismarcki an ideals were confirmed, particularly in relation to the failure to incorporate social protagonists in the development of these policies and the involvement of political parties, who serve the interests of distinct social classes, thereby perpetuating the interests of the strongest groups and creating an unequal protection structure and hierarchized benefits. This leads to a population with a low vindicatory performance and reforms that have distinct objectives and are aimed at the private system. Consequently, citizens with equal rights are excluded from the concession of rights and the formation process of these social policies..

Downloads

How to Cite

The Creation of Social Welfare Policies: Comparative Analysis between German and Brazilian Experiences. (2017). Global Journal of Human-Social Science, 17(C2), 29-40. https://socialscienceresearch.org/index.php/GJHSS/article/view/2207

Download Citation

References

Cristóbal Molina Navarrete (2010) Nuevos contratos indefinidos en la reforma: ¿Modelos de transición-transacción para estabilizar al personal investigador público?. 23(1), 56-79.

J Alber (1989) Der sozialstaat in der Bundesrepublik 1950-1983.

C Araújo, De (2008) A influência do constitucionalismo alemão no constitucionalismo brasileiro. 16(2).

M Batich (2004) Previdência do trabalhador: Uma trajetória inesperada. 18(3), 33-40.

A Börsch-Supan, R Schnabel (1999) Social Security and Retirement in Germany.

Börsch-Supan, C Wilke (2003) The german social security system: How it was and how it will be.

Ivanete Boschetti (2003) Implicações da reforma da previdência na seguridade social brasileira. 15(1), 57-96.

J Braga, S &goes De Paula (1986) Unknown Title.

M Caetano (1226) Determinantes da sustentabilidade e do custo previdenciário: aspectos conceituais e comparações interna cionais.Ipea.

G Costa, Da (2005) EMPREGO DA METODOLOGIA MILK RUN NUMA EMPRESA DE METAIS SANITÁRIOS.

G Esping-Andersen (1991) As três economias políticas do welfarestate. 24.

R Issen (1989) Marktwirtschaft und sozialstaatsgebot in: 40 jahre sozialstaat bundesrepublik Deutschland. 205-2014.

P Krause (1989) Baden-Baden. 0, 17-17.

J Malloy (1979) The politics of social security in Brazil.

M Medeiros (2001) A trajetória do WelfareState no Brasil: Papel redistributivo das políticas sociais dos anos 1930 aos anos 1990. 852.

J Oliveira, S De A.&teixeira (1989) IM) Previdência social: 60 anos de história da previdência no Brasil. 2, 360.

P Oertzen (1982) O estado do Bem-Estar e a Sociedade: O caso da Alemanha-Quais as mudanças ocorridas? Que futuro?.

M Ribeiro, E &ribeiro (2001) Anais do(a) XLIV ANPAD 2020 EnANPAD. 25.

G Ritter (1991) Der sozialstaat. Entstehung und entwicklung im internationalen vergleich.

Winfried Schmähl (2002) Paradigm Shift in German Pension Policy: Measures Aiming at a New Public-Private Mix and their Effects. 11.

S Schneider, C (1998) O uso do método comparativo nas ciências sociais. 9, 49-87.

Sparplan (2014) Struktur der altervorsorge. 25.

O Sund (1982) O Estado do Bem Estar Alemão: Propósitos, realizações e deficiências.

L Thompson (2000) Mais velha e mais sábia: A economia dos sistemas previdenciários. 160.

André Tropiano, Neiva Vieira Da Cunha (1998) Arena pública na internet em defesa da universidade pública no Brasil: Estratégias de #UERJResiste. 111-138.

(1989) Dem sozialstaatsgebot verpflichtet in: 40 jahre sozialstaat bundesrepublik Deutschland. 161-168.