The effectiveness of Civil Society Organizations (CSOs) in Public Sector Construction Oversight in Nigeria: Challenges and strategies for improvement

Emmanuel Tayo Adu; Familoye, Olajide Stephen; Adeoye Olugbenga Adewolu

doi:10.34257/GJHSSAVOL25IS7PG51

Authors

Emmanuel Tayo Adu
Familoye, Olajide Stephen
Adeoye Olugbenga Adewolu

Abstract

Persistent governance failures in public construction projects highlight the need for strategic interventions, with Civil Society Organizations (CSOs) providing a potential pathway toward more transparent, inclusive, and sustainable infrastructure delivery. This study investigates the factors influencing the effectiveness of CSO oversight in Nigeria's construction sector and explores strategies for strengthening their role. Data were collected through a survey of 305 respondents-including CSO staff, government officials, and project beneficiaries-and analyzed using mean score and the Kruskal-Wallis rank test. Findings indicate that CSO oversight is constrained less by technical limitations than by structural and political barriers. Limited information access and weak coordination are further compounded by entrenched patronage, institutional fragmentation, and low civic legitimacy. The study also shows that meaningful contributions to accountability and inclusive governance depend on aligning foundational, operational, and adaptive strategies. Addressing these challenges requires more than transparency tools, calling for broader political and institutional reforms. The study recommends strengthening CSO oversight through legal and regulatory safeguards, diversified and sustainable funding, enhanced technical capacity, and context-sensitive collaborative approaches.

Downloads

Article PDF

How to Cite

The effectiveness of Civil Society Organizations (CSOs) in Public Sector Construction Oversight in Nigeria: Challenges and strategies for improvement. (2026). Global Journal of Human-Social Science, 25(H5), 63-78. https://doi.org/10.34257/GJHSSAVOL25IS7PG51

Download Citation

References

John Ackerman (2004) Co-Governance for Accountability: Beyond "Exit" and "Voice". 32(3), 447-463.

S Adebayo, D Omolara, Y Falade (2022) Cultural sensitivity and community integration in CSO project monitoring: Lessons from African rural projects. 8(3), 187-204.

A Adeyemi, O Aluko, O Adebayo (2022) The impact of political environment on the effectiveness of civil society organizations in public construction oversight. 22(3), 297-308.

T Adeyemi, R Afolabi, O Olatunde (2022) Enhancing CSO-government collaboration in public sector projects: A case study of Nigeria. 15(2), 134-148.

O Afolabi, K Musa, J Bello (2021) Accountability in public sector construction: The role of civil society organizations in Nigeria. 22(3), 55-69.

(2020) African Development Bank (AfDB). 46(12).

T Agbaje, C Eze, M Adeoye (2023) Capacity building and professional development in civil society organizations: Enhancing oversight in public sector projects. 14(2), 120-132.

A Agbede, O Oloyede (2023) Collaborative approaches for strengthening oversight in public sector construction projects: Evidence from Nigeria. 17(3), 443-455.

A Agbede, O Oloyede, I Oloyede (2023) Collaborations between civil society organizations and government: Implications for project delivery in Nigeria. 21(1), 123-136.

M Ajibade, E Onyekachi, D Nwosu (2020) Legal frameworks for CSO engagement in Nigeria's public projects: Opportunities and challenges. 18(1), 93-109.

O Akintola, L Afolabi (2020) The role of civil society in improving accountability in public sector construction. 23(1), 45-57.

A Akintola, L Ojo, F Lawal (2020) Evaluating financial performance in public construction projects: The role of oversight organizations. 45(3), 215-230.

O Aluko, E Chukwu, F Ezeokoli (2022) Governance challenges in public sector construction projects in Nigeria: Implications for stakeholders. 7(1), 34-46.

F Amadi, I Odede (2023) Financial sustainability models for CSOs in project oversight: Diversified funding and independence. 22(1), 45-60.

C Amoah, D Ahadzie, A Danso (2020) Challenges in public sector construction: The role of oversight. 12(4), 233-245.

Helmut Anheier, Stefan Toepler (2014) Financing Nonprofit Organizations. 358-397.

C Ansell, A Gash (2008) Collaborative governance in theory and practice. 18(4), 543-571.

M Bauhr, M Grimes (2014) Indignation or resignation: The implications of transparency for societal accountability. 27(2), 291-320.

John Bertot, Paul Jaeger, Justin Grimes (2010) Using ICTs to create a culture of transparency: E-government and social media as openness and anti-corruption tools for societies. 27(3), 264-271.

D Brinkerhoff, A Wetterberg (2016) Addressing governance challenges in fragile states: Engaging theory and practice.

A Bryman (2016) Social research methods.

(2017) State of civil society report.

(2022) Enabling environment national assessments: Global synthesis report.

(2007) Spaces for change? The politics of citizen participation in new democratic arenas.

J Creswell (2014) Research design: Qualitative, quantitative, and mixed methods approaches.

(2024) "Can we hold out much longer?". 117-146.

P Drucker (2006) The effective executive: The definitive guide to getting the right things done.

S Famiyeh, C Amoatey, E Adaku, C Agbenohevi (2017) Major causes of construction time and cost overruns: A case of selected educational sector projects in Ghana. 15(2), 181-198.

Jonathan Fox (2015) Social Accountability: What Does the Evidence Really Say?. 72, 346-361.

R Freeman (2010) Strategic management: A stakeholder approach.

Archon Fung, Mary Graham, David Weil (2007) Full Disclosure.

P Garg, R Chatterjee (2021) Role of civil society organizations in rural infrastructure development in India: A case study of accountability mechanisms. 32(4), 45-61.

J Gaventa (2020) Power and participation revisited: Citizen engagement and participatory governance. 137, 105-217.

J Gaventa (2020) Power and powerlessness revisited: Building strategic concepts in practice. 51(2), 3-20.

A Ghaus Pasha (2005) Role of civil society organizations in governance.

Merilee Grindle (2011) Going Local.

S Hassan, A Nadir, A Abubakar (2023) Achieving sustainable development goals through public infrastructure projects: A case study in Nigeria. 18(2), 221-233.

Goran Hyden, Julius Court, Kenneth Mease (2018) Making Sense of Governance.

M Ibrahim (2022) Change management in KM adoption in Nigerian firms. 12(2), 178-192.

(2023) Protecting democratic space for civil society.

(2019) Organisational capacity building: Lessons and recommendations.

A Joshi, P Houtzager (2019) Widgets or watchdogs? Conceptual explorations in social accountability. 21(1), 1-22.

Aynur Kazaz, Ekrem Manisali, Serdar Ulubeyli (2008) EFFECT OF BASIC MOTIVATIONAL FACTORS ON CONSTRUCTION WORKFORCE PRODUCTIVITY IN TURKEY/PAGRINDINIŲ MOTYVACIJOS VEIKSNIŲ ĮTAKA STATYBOS PRODUKTYVUMUI TURKIJOJE. 14(2), 95-106.

Margaret Keck, Kathryn Sikkink (1998) Activists beyond Borders.

M Khan, A Abubakar, I Yusuf (2021) Corruption and delays in public construction projects: An African perspective. 17(2), 91-105.

S Kosack, A Fung (2014) Governing for transparency and accountability.

S Kosack, A Fung (2014) Does transparency improve governance. 17, 65-87.

S Kosack, A Fung (2014) Governing through transparency: When and why does open government work?. 27(1), 1-24.

Helen Lingard, Steve Rowlinson (2018) Occupational Health and Safety in Construction Project Management.

R Mcgee, D Edwards (2021) Opening governance -Change, continuity and conceptual ambiguity. 15(2), 169-188.

Rosie Mcgee, John Gaventa (2010) Shifting Power? Assessing the Impact of Transparency and Accountability Initiatives. 2011(383), 1-39.

R Mcgee, J Gaventa (2019) The impact of transparency and accountability initiatives. 37(1), 28-46.

A Musa, A Adeyemi, O Adebayo (2022) The role of civil society organizations in enhancing transparency in public sector construction projects: A Nigerian perspective. 12(1), 45-60.

K Mutuku, L Mwangi (2022) The role of civil society in enhancing transparency and accountability in Kenya's public infrastructure projects. 39(5), 120-138.

D Narayan, S Choudhury (2020) Civil society and accountability in India's infrastructure projects: Lessons from grassroots mobilization. 30(7), 871-884.

J Ngugi, T Mwangi, L Kamau (2022) Political Risk : Countering the Impact on Your Business. 15, 95-108.

E Obi, P Agwu (2021) Civil society organization accountability within governance networks. 14, 91-108.

K Obi, A Aluko (2021) Transparency and accountability in civil society organizations: Best practices for self-regulation. 13(2), 78-91.

(2007) Principles for integrity in public procurement.

(2021) Enhancing the role of civil society in infrastructure governance.

A Ogunbanjo, J Ajayi (2021) Tools for Construction Quality Improvement. 18, 215-266.

T Ojo (2019) Apprenticeship schemes in Nigerian construction: Combining education and on-the-job training. 21(2), 223-238.

A Oladapo, O Afolabi, J Owoeye (2021) Transportation infrastructure and economic growth in Nigeria: An empirical analysis. 150, 72-85.

I Omoleke, A Adebayo (2020) Civil society and public procurement oversight in Nigeria: The need for institutionalized participatory governance. 6(2), 87-104.

I Omoleke, T Adebayo (2020) Governance and public procurement in Nigeria: Managing accountability and transparency deficits. 32(1), 45-61.

F Omotayo (2021) Barriers to KM adoption in Nigerian construction firms. 25(5), 899-913.

Anisley Sanchez (2021) Open Contracting and Open Data in the United States: A Global Comparison (DISCUSSION DRAFT).

J Pallant (2007) Survival manual, a step-by-step guide for data analysis using SPSS for windows.

A Saidu, O Ayodele (2023) Leveraging technology for KM in the construction industry. 28(1), 85-101.

L Salamon, S Sokolowski, R List (2003) Global Civil Society: An Overview.

A Shah (2007) Participatory Budgeting.

A Smith, X Chen, K Patel (2022) Independence and neutrality in civil society oversight: A case for political and financial autonomy. 11(4), 205-219.

R Tandon (2008) Society for Participatory Research in Asia (PRIA).

Anwesha Chakraborty, Ina Kubbe (2020) Improving Transparency in Service Delivery to Fight Corruption? Mapping Multi-Stakeholder Voices on Digitization in the Indian Public Healthcare Sector.

(2022) Addressing financial discrepancies in water projects in Tanzania.

(2018) People-centered urban development.

(2020) Capacity building for local governance.

Schoiswohl Michael (2020) United Nations Development Programme (UNDP).

(2014) CSO sustainability index for Sub-Saharan Africa.

(2023) Despite progress, Nigerian CSOs struggle to influence policy, say experts.

K Wong (2020) Localization of development and inclusive participation. 30(4), 476-488.

(2020) Enhancing government effectiveness and transparency: The fight against corruption.

(2020) Ensuring timely delivery of public projects in India.

J Yap, A Lock (2017) Analysing the benefits, techniques, tools and challenges of knowledge management practices in the Malaysian construction SMEs. 15(6), 803-825.