Pursuing Marriage Equality in Four Democracies: Canada, the United States, Belgium, and Spain

David Paternotte; Susan Gluck Mezey

Authors

David Paternotte
Susan Gluck Mezey

Keywords:

equality, marriage, sexual orientation, courts, legislatures, political parties

Abstract

Viewing litigation as an effective weapon in minority group politics, gay and lesbian rights activists in Canada and the United States turned to the judicial arena, seeking the courts' affirmation of their fundamental right to marry. In contrast, Belgian and Spanish activists refrained from constitutional litigation, choosing instead to pursue marriage equality by appealing to national legislative and executive institutions, and developing insider strategies within the political parties. This paper explores the asymmetry between the four countries: it highlights the key differences and similarities among them and offers preliminary explanations for the disparities in strategies for marriage equality. It concludes that the strategies developed by same-sex marriage advocates in these four cases reflected their countries' legal and political environment as well as their historical approach to social reform.

Downloads

How to Cite

Pursuing Marriage Equality in Four Democracies: Canada, the United States, Belgium, and Spain. (2013). Global Journal of Human-Social Science, 13(28), 1-11. https://socialscienceresearch.org/index.php/GJHSS/article/view/

Download Citation

References

Craig Bavis (1999) Vriend v. Alberta, Law v. Canada, Ontario v. M. and H.: The Latest Stepson the Winding Path to Substantive Equality. 37, 683-714. https://doi.org/10.29173/alr1463

Beck, Volcker (2011) Volcker 2011 The Social Struggle of a Minority for Equal Rights In The Development of Laws Pertaining to Homosexuality and Transsexuality in Germany Ed. 76-81.

Mary Bernstein, Nancy Naples (2010) Sexual Citizenship and the Pursuit of Relationship Recognition Policies in Australia and the United States. 38(1-2), 132-156.

(2011) Altered States: Legal Structuring and Relationship Recognition in the U.S., Canada, and Australia.

Paul Borghs, Bart Eeckhout (2009) LGB Rights in Belgium, 1999-2007: A Historical Survey of a Velvet Revolution. 24(1), 1-28. https://doi.org/10.1093/lawfam/ebp013

Kerman Calvo (2011) Spain: Building reciprocal relations between lesbian and gay organizations and the State. 167-180.

Rachel Cichowski (2007) The European Court and Civil Society: Litigation, Mobilization and Govern-ance.

Christine Davies (2008) Canadian Same-Sex Marriage Litigation: Individual Rights, Community Strategy. 66, 101-134.

Jeffrey Friesen (1996) When Common Law Countries Interpret Civil Codes. 15, 1-28.

Guido Groeseneken (1993) Het homohuwelijk. Het verschil tussen strategie en taktiek!.

Yuri Guaiana (2011) Dal cuore delle coppie al cuore del diritto.

Kristen Hansen (2004) The U.S. Legal System: Common Values, Uncommon Procedures. 69, 689-726.

Chris Hilson (2002) New Social Movements: The Role of Legal Opportunity. 9(2), 238-255. https://doi.org/10.1080/13501760110120246

Loveday Hodson (2011) NGOs and the Struggle for Human Rights in Europe.

Thomas Keck (2009) Beyond Backlash: Assessing the Impact of Judicial decisions on LGBT Rights. 43, 151-186.

Kensie Kim (2010) Mixed Systems in Legal Origins Analysis. 83, 693-728.

Kelly Kollman (2009) European institutions, transnational networks and national same-sex unions policy: when soft law hits harder. 15(1), 37-53. https://doi.org/10.1080/13569770802674204

Michael Mc Cann (2004) Law and Social Movements. 506-522.

Caroline Mécary (2013) L'amour et la loi.

José Pichardo Galán (2011) We are family (or not). Social and legal recognition of same-sex relationships and lesbian and gay families in Spain. 14, 503-622.

Daniel Pinello (2003) Gay Rights and American Law.

Raquel Platero (2007) Love and the State: Gay Marriage in Spain. 15(3), 329-340. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10691-007-9064-z

Fernando Sánchez Amillategui, Luis Royo (2006) A „master image‟ of inequality: The Spanish CGPJ report on same-sex marriage. 13-15.

Stuart Scheingold (2004) The Politics of Rights.

Miriam Smith (2008) Political Institutions and Lesbian and Gay Rights in the United States and Canada.

Kees Waaldijk (2000) Civil Developments: Patterns of Reform in the Legal Position of Same-Sex Partners in Europe. 17, 62-88.

Robert Wintemute (2011) Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity Discrimination: The Case Law of the European Court of Human Rights and the Court of Justice of the European Union.

Susan Mezey, Gluck (2007) Queers in Court.

(2009) Gay Families and the State: The Quest for Equality.

David Paternotte (2008) Les lieux d'activisme : le «mariage gai» en Belgique, en France et en Espagne. 41, 935-952.

(2011) Revendiquer le "mariage gay" Belgique, France, Espagne.

(2012) La juridification ou la saisie des minorités par le droit: La revendication du droit au mariage entre personnes du même sexe. 31, 93-112.

(2013) La France: Entre stratégies parlementaire ET judiciaire?. 14-15.

(2001) EGALE v. Canada.

EGALE v, Canada (2003)

Egan Canada (1995) Egan v.

Halpern Canada (2002) Halpern v. 321.

Halpern Canada (2003) Halpern v.

(2002) Hendricks v. Quebec.

(2004) Hendricks v. Quebec.

Vriend Alberta (1998) Vriend v.

Brown v. Board of Education (1954) Brown v. Board of Education. 347, 483.

Goodridge v. 798.

(2008)

Kerrigan v. Commissioner of Public Health. 957.

Lawrence Texas (2003) Lawrence v. Texas, 539 U.S. 558 (2003).

Romer Evans Romer v. Evans.

(2013) United States v. Windsor.