Comparative Study of BRICS Countries on Renewable Energy

Table of contents

1. I. Introduction

very year, we feel the temperatures increase in comparison to the previous year due to global warming. The main reasons for global warming are increase in automobiles, electrical appliances and pollution caused by industries. The conventional way of power generation is thermal and nuclear power plants. Nuclear power plants are costly and have limitations. Due to heavy carbon emissions causing air pollution, there is a shift to cleaner sources of power generation such as solar, hydro and wind energy globally. Due to climate change targets set it is essential to reduce CO 2 emissions by reducing dependence on thermal power plants and shifting to renewable energy. In this paper, a brief comparative study of the electricity mix, energy consumption and carbon emissions of BRICS countries was carried out. Study was also carried out on India's initiative on trade deals with BRICS countries through 'Make in India' for renewable energy products.

2. a) Need for study of Renewable Energy Sector

The various methods of power generation are: 1. Thermal 2. Hydro-Electric 3. Nuclear. 4. Solar. 5. Wind Energy. 6. Bio-Gas.

Among the above methods of energy generation mix the dependence is on coal based thermal power plants in many countries. However coal based power plants are harmful to the environment and human life as these plants emit heavy carbon dioxide (CO 2 ) and they are one of main cause of pollution. Also as these thermal power plants have become old and proper maintenance is not carried out, they operate at very low efficiency. Nuclear power plants are costly. Globally, nuclear is not a preferred option due to problems in nuclear disposables and Chernobyl accidents. Germany has plans to decommission all their nuclear plants by 2025 and replace them with wind turbines solar, wind energy and bio-gas are clean source of energy and due protection of surrounding environment there is a need to either shift or go for renewable energy.

3. Key issues encountered in Energy Production and Consumption in BRICS countries

There are some key issues to be encountered in Energy Production and Consumption in BRICS countries are:

Balance of interests, transparency predictability of supply and demand area on top priority. Due to substantial increase in energy consumption and supply being restricted matching demand becomes very difficult task for power distribution companies in BRICS country. Also if excess electricity is produced it becomes a waste and electricity is to be supplied and consumed immediately and cannot be stored.

In BRICS countries the demand for electric supply is growing every year due to urbanization and industrialization. The BRICS countries need to share their knowledge and experience in the related areas of energy planning, production and promoting mutual energy cooperation.

BRICS countries should address the following priority areas to enhance their energy security. 1. Enhancing awareness of the needs of the energyproducing and energy-consuming counties. Per capita carbon emissions is given in the following Figure 1 Figure 1: Per capita carbon emissions Globally all countries are realizing that coalbased thermal power generation is costly and also harmful to the environment and human health as it causes heavy pollution. The BRICS counties together contributed to about 38 percent of the global carbon emissions in 2014. The biggest share of 24 percent is China's, followed by India in the above study of carbon emissions of BRICS countries. Figure 1 show that only Brazil and India remain below world average in terms of per capita emissions. The reason being India's energy consumption is relatively low and Brazil uses hydro power and bio-fuels. Roughly the same emissions China emits as Europeans per person. The highest per capita carbon among BRICS countries is Russia, followed by South Africa. Considering aspect of reducing pollution has there is growing demand for shift to renewable energy.

The researcher had carried out SWOT Analysis of renewable energy sector and the same is indicated in The following Figure 3 shows the installed renewable capacity in Brazil Source: www.greenpeace.de Key findings 1. The main energy generation in Brazil was hydro power. 2. Brazil was focusing attention on building hydro power since2000. 3. In 2014, brazil built roughly 3 Giga watts of hydro power and therefore totaling to 84 Giga watts of hydro power 4. Brazil had shared the Itaipu dam hydroelectric facility with neighboring Paraguay. This was the second largest hydroelectric facility worldwide. 5. Hydro power plants are based on the natural resources and are clean source of energy. However there are great objections and protests by environmentalists on this issue. This type of power generation depends on rain fall which will be purely Comparative study of BRICS countries on Renewable Energy depending on nature and carry a great amount of uncertainty. With environment destruction, the river water levels are decreasing year -by-year. From the farmer's point of view they lose employment and livelihood if the land is grabbed by the government for building of dams 6. A number of plants were in the middle of Amazon forest directly in and therefore local communities 7. The wind farms were installed in Brazil and the capacity of these wind farms was 6 Giga watts by end of 2014. 8. The wind farms may reach 16.5 Giga watts by end of 2019.

9. The ten year plan of Brazil's energy sector published in September 2015 was with focus on increasing solar plant capacity for 23.6 Giga watts by 2023. Brazil had installed only 15 megawatts solar plants by end of 2014.The solar power plants are dependent on heat spots and may be operative during part of the year and during monsoon and winter the solar plants will partially give output. Also the photo voltaic cells are costly and due to heavy taxation and duties the consumers are reluctant in using them.

4. Russia

The following Figure 4 shows Russia's electricity generation mix 2000 2014 Source: www.greenpeace.de Key findings 1. Russia is a major exporter of oil, natural gas and coal to the world. Russia is a major exporter to Germany whom Russia the largest supplier of fossil fuels. 2. Russia is the largest in terms of land area and has large resources but has not concentrated on renewable but has focused their attention on producing the electricity by conventional means. 3. Carbon emissions dropped in Russia mainly due collapse in economy in 1990 and financial crisis in 2008. 4. 50 percent of electricity is generated by natural gas as a result the coal consumption has dropped slightly to 16 percent. 5. In terms of dominance of primary energy consumption, about16 percent of electricity is generated by conventional energy.

6. The share of nuclear had fallen to 1 percent from 17 percent of the total energy 7. The hydroelectric power accounted to about 16 percent. 8. The Coal based thermal power were amounting to 16 percent of electricity generation Comparative study of BRICS countries on Renewable Energy

The following Figure 7 shows India's renewable power capacity 2000-2014 d) The Power scenario in India India had 306 GW of total generation capacity as of March 2015 and the government plans to add another 250 GW of total generation capacity by 2025.Frequent supply interruptions and poor power quality has driven many industries to develop captive generation plant having combined capacity of about 25,000 MW. Thakur, T, Chairman and Managing Director, Power Trading Corporation (PTC), foresee electricity demand growing 7.2 percent per annum, assuming GDP growth of 9 percent per annum and on an elasticity of 0.8 due to energy efficient technologies and other energy conservation and demand-side management measures. "Keeping this in view, energy generation will need to increase to a level of 1,470,000 million units (MU) by 2016-17 from a level of 1,038,000 MU in 2011-12 to service the increased demand", he calculated 1 . Presently, "Six millions Indians do not have access to electricity", stated Mr. Sethi, S, Principal Advisor (Energy), Planning Commission. 2 e) Challenges faced by power sector in India Following are some of the challenges faced by power sector in India-1. Coal Shortage-presently about 74% of power generated is by thermal power plants. There is a severe coal shortage and it is a big political issue on assignment of coal blocks.

2. The demand for power is going up every year with urbanization and industrialization. There are hardly any power plants built up. The power plants require huge investment and the returns are after many years. This aspect makes investment very unattractive for private players and the investors are reluctant to make investments. 3. Presently many industries have their own captive power plants as the availability of power is uncertain .If no power supply is available industries, it can lead to labor unrest. These captive power plants are economically unviable for SMEs as the costs of operation will go up and they will not be able to compete in the market. 4. The distribution companies are making huge losses. 5. Majority of power plants are very old and running at almost 50% of capacity. Electricity boards have no money to modernize them. 6. Load shedding-one of the main reasons for power failure is load shedding which is result of inadequate power supply vis-a-vis power generation. 7. Price volatility-the supply tends to become constrained as generation and transmission reach their physical limit and electricity demand is very inelastic 8. Wise has recommended that Maharashtra make optimum use of its land and water resources to achieve low carbon and sustainable energy for future development. 3 The total target for 2022 is 175 Giga watts of renewable energy, 60 Giga watts will be wind power, 10Giga watts of bio mass and new hydro consist of about 5 Giga watts.

generating capacity. Coal fired power plants account to about 74 percent of the electricity generation mix. Comparative study of BRICS countries based on the energy and green economy report with reference to renewable energy The primary objective of the green economy working group was to address the challenges relating to energy security of supply, energy social equity and environment sustainability within BRICS countries, to achieve the goal of secure and sustainable energy for all. This objective was to be achieved through the following a. b. Among BRICS countries, China had carried out maximum trades for renewable energy 17 c. The following table 3 shows the specific companies or corporations that had key and important promotion trade and investment ties with the other BRICS countries and Africa for renewable energy. Process knowledge sharing and transfer under technology transfer agreement for the renewable products. iii.

Import of passive infrastructure for solar power projects. iv.

Alliance with Brazil for bio-ethanol production, the fermentation technology for production of 2 nd generation bio fuels could be adopted in India. India had also developed globally competitive manufacturing partnership and business in export of Wind Turbines and its components. The following table 4 shows future plans of BRICS countries to curb carbon emissions and share of renewable power by 2030

5. Recommendations

1. Brazil must tap its renewable energy potential 2. In Brazil, deforestation needs to be curtailed in the Amazon and Cerrado regions.

3. Russia should international renewable projects with neighboring countries like China, Mongolia, and Kazakhstan. 4. Russia to reorient subsidies from new oil and gas extraction as well as from nuclear power projects in favor of renewable energy. 5. Russia to develop ambitious targets in renewable energy. 6. In India about 45 percent of consumers do not have access to electricity. Indian government to ensure effective implementation of power projects to stick to a pledge to provide 24/7 electricity to all 7. Forests should be off-limits for coal mining in India.

India must impose a restriction on coal mining in forest areas. 8. Indian prime minister said that his ambition is on efforts to ensure universal access for India's poor people. The state electricity boards and power distribution companies to ensure that Indian prime minister's ambition s are fulfilled. The state government must support in long term goal of phase out fossil fuels and nuclear energy by 2050 9. India has many hot spots and being tropical country, sun rays abundant are available for fixing solar panels on roof top. Indian government to incentivize and make it mandatory for all future buildings to use solar panels only 10. China to take proper steps to reduce dependence on coal consumption. 11. China to make concentrated efforts in implementing renewable energy projects in future. 12. The South African government must revise the country's electricity plan which was published in 2011(IPR 2010). 13. The current expansion of the coal sector in South Africa must be stopped. No further coal fired power plants to be built after Medupi and Kusile power plants. 14. The recent plan in South Africa ignores the massive advantage of natural resources available in the country. 15. Opportunities need to be created for manufacture of renewable energy in South Africa. 16. BRICS countries have shown keen interest in making FDI in India by signing MOUs for renewable energy products. It is recommended that all states should cooperate and ease out on doing business. 17. To achieve sustainable growth, BRICS countries need to promote value-added trade amongst BRICS countries by focusing their attention to cooperative investments in energy projects in BRICS countries. 16 V.

6. Conclusion

The electricity generation varies from country to country among BRICKS countries. There is heavy reliance on coal in India, China and South Africa. Brazil has good natural resources and has developed mainly on hydro plants as a source electricity generation. A political will and efforts are required by BRICS countries (barring Brazil) in shifting to renewable energy by tapping all natural resources. Indian government has invited manufacturing and trade initiative between BRICS for renewable products through 'Make in India'. China had carried out maximum trades for renewable energy.

Figure 1. Figure 2 :
2Figure 2: Brazil's electricity generation mix Source: www.greenpeace.de
Figure 2. Figure 3 :
3Figure 3: The installed renewable capacity in Brazil
Figure 3. Figure 4 :
4Figure 4: Russia's electricity generation mix2000 2014
Figure 4. Figure 5 :
5Figure 5: The installed renewable capacity in Russia2000 2014 Source: www.greenpeace.de `
Figure 5. Figure 8 :
8Figure 8: China's electricity generation mix 2000 2014 Source: www.greenpeace.de
Figure 6.
c. Technology transfer for the energy saving technologies
Figure 7.
Figure 8.
Figure 9.
Figure 10.
Figure 11.
2. Extending mutual support for diversification of
energy supplies
3. Promoting universal access to energy.
4. Increasing energy efficiency.
Note: E 5. e. Encourage research on practical implementation of sustainable development in the BRICS countries, taking into account national interests. f
Figure 12. Table
Figure 13. Table 1 :
1
Strengths Weaknesses
? Solution to reduce global warming ? Depends on vagaries of nature
? Effective utilization of natural resources ? Less efficient
? Pollution can be controlled ? Changing consumer's mind set is difficult
? The initial higher costs can be set off due to ? Farmers and rural consumers may get affected due to
benefits of cleaner energy dams built
Opportunities Threats
? Effective ways to reduce carbon emissions ? Due higher costs involved, the consumers are reluctant
to shift
? To innovate new ways of energy generation ? Threats from social activist
? To save the earth from environmental pollution
? To serve mankind
? To save trees being cut
? To market green products
Source: 'Develop clean energy and save energy or perish' 4 .
II. Research Methodology a) Objectives c) Comparative study of BRICS Countries on Renewable Energy The researcher considered the following
1. To examine the various resources available in sequence for comparative study of BRICS Countries on
BRICS countries for electricity generation. Renewable Energy
2. To study trade between India and BRICS countries for renewable energy products. 3. To carry out SWOT analysis of renewable energy sector. 4. To carry out Comparative study of BRICS Countries on Renewable Energy 1. Brazil 2. Russia. 3. India. 4. China 5. South Africa.
5. To study the challenges faced by power sector in
India
b) Scope of the study
Comparative study of BRICS Countries on
Renewable Energy Major parameters considered for
study were Energy generation mix, Major method of
power generation, present methods of producing
Renewable Energy with their emphasis on shifting to
Renewable Energy for BRICS countries.
III. Method of Data Collection
Secondary data collected by visiting web sites
and research articles/papers.
a) Limitation of the study
Except India it was not possible to gather data
on challenges faced by power sector from other BRICS
countries
b) Scope of the further research
Comparative study of the remaining countries
on Renewable Energy can be carried to reduce pollution
and global warming
Figure 14.
blasts in Japan, has raised some red flags on
India's nuclear programmes, including safety of
multi -nuclear parks like Jaitapur India has a target
of 63 GW by 2024.The problems faced in India is
that planned nuclear are not completed in time.
Nuclear Power of about 5 percent of electricity
generation mix. Also nuclear power is more
expensive as compared to coal or renewable
energy. The council of Scientific and Industrial
research (CSIR) estimated the cost of electricity
from nuclear to be Rs 1/Kwh, compared to Rs
0.80/kwh form coal and Rs 0.80/Kwh from solar and
Rs 0.60/Kwh from wind energy. 4
4. Hydro Power: Hydro plants are based on the natural
resources and are clean source of energy. However
there are great objections and protests by
environmentalists on this issue. With environment
destruction, the river water levels are decreasing
year -by-year. From the farmer's point of view they
lose employment and livelihood if the land is
grabbed by the government for building of dams.
5. With the above facts it high time to develop
renewable power in India in the form of: a. Wind
Energy. b. Small Hydro Power, c. Co-generation,
( B ) Global Journal of Human Social Science efficiency compared to the plants in other countries. By the end of 2014, coal based thermal plants account to about 74 percent of electricity generation mix. 2. Natural reserves in India is around 0.6% of world reserves. There is heavy reliance on import of liquefied natural gas which has become very costly. Even world natural gas production will reach its maximum limits in the next 15-20 years. 3. Nuclear Power: In India, the 'vision 2020, for nuclear energy foresees addition of 20.000 MW by 2020.New uranium mining sites in the north-east Key findings 1. The most common method used for power generation is by building thermal power plants. India had 306 GW of total generation capacity as of March 2015 However, the major drawback of thermal power generation type is environment pollution. According to world reports, 40% of air pollution is due to thermal energy. Another limitation of using coal is heavy reliance on imported coal in India due to inferior quality available in local market. Thermal plants have become old and need to modernize as present plants operate at50% less Bagasse, d. Bio-power , e. Wind Energy and f. Solar Photovoltaic system. 6. Renewable sources like wind, solar photovoltaic, solar thermal and bio-energy sources like municipal solid and liquid waste, industrial waste, Bagasse and tapioca (bio-methanation) and small hydro plants have potential to develop in future. The clean energy technology action plan for Maharashtra, prepared by Pune-based World Institute of Sustainable Energy (Wise), has estimated that Maharashtra State has a potential to generate 57,000 MW to 2, 13,000 MW of renewable energy.
India are facing stiff resistance from local people.
Even though it a known fact that India has a vast
reserve of thorium, these thorium reactors are not
proven. Also globally, nuclear is not a preferred
option due to problems in nuclear disposables and
Chernobyl accidents. Germany has plans to
decommission all their nuclear plants by 2025 and
replace them with wind turbines. With Fukushima
Note: Irrational tariffs-The tariff is fixed by State Electric Regulatory Committees and revision is possible only on the sanction from SERCs the State Government Figure7: I ndia's renewable power capacity 2000-2014 s -Year 2016
Figure 15.
1. South Africa depends heavily on coal based power
plants as about 92 percent of electricity generating
mix and this level has remained unchanged since
last 15 years.
2. South African government planned for 9600 MW of
nuclear power.
3. South Africa's per capita carbon emissions were found to be above level of European Union since 2008. 4. A study by an impendent consultancy from 2006 found that South Africa has a potential to get 75 percent of its electricity by mid-century. 5. In 2010, a report from UNEP found that South Africa has a potential to get 50 percent of its renewable electricity by 2030. 6. Since 2010 the cost of both solar and wind power have drastically come down in South Africa and have become cheaper than coal and nuclear power. 7. An impendent study by CSIR found that renewable energy from South Africa's first wind and solar projects created 4 billion and more financial benefits to South Africa than they cost during first six months of 2015. f) Trade between India and BRICS Countries for Renewable Energy Products With 'Make in India' imitative of Indian Government has given boost to trades between India and BRICS countries for renewable energy products Key findings a. Joint statement on 7 th India-Brazil joint commission meeting and agreement on November 18-19, 2015India expressed satisfaction with Brazil Investment in renewable energy. India apprised Brazil on the relaxed FDI policies and 'Make in India, initiative. India invited more investments from Brazil during this meeting. The ministers of both countries stressed the need for consolidation strategic partnership that strives for equity and transparency in the spheres of international finance, trade, climate change and sustainable development. Both country representatives acknowledge the complementarities in the mining sector and agreed to expedite signing of the MOU on cooperation in miming between their respective Geological Surveys. The Ministers of both countries emphasized the importance of increasing the share of renewable sources in the global mix. They expressed interest in the area of biomass, hydro-power, solar and wind energy technology. b. The energy should act like a catalyst to create sustainable development and economy there by attaining energy security in the BRICS region. c. India will seek cooperation between BRICS countries on standards. Russia and Brazil are demanding a mechanism to link schemes such as Make in India, Digital India, and Smart City Mission with special emphasis on sectors like renewable energy and infrastructure.
Figure 16.
Comparative study of BRICS countries on Renewable Energy
Year 2016
b. Promotion of Business Co-operation.
c. Technology transfer and Development.
( B ) d. Forming multilateral Parternerships to invest in Third Party Countries and multilateral business projects
Global Journal of Human Social Science - e. Advisory role. Key findings a. The following table 2 shows the specific industries and sectors wanted to promote ,trade and have investment ties with the other BRICS countries and Africa
s
Figure 17. Table 2 :
2
BRICS countries and Africa
Brazil Russia India China South Africa
Greater focus on Focus on Hydro power, Renewable like Renewable especially Renewable energy
sustainable fuels bi fuels, technology Solar, wind and hydropower power research & development,
such as bio fuels transfer on energy bio energy off grid solutions linked to
saving technologies, renewable energy, hydro-
hydro power, bio fuels power, manufacturing
hydro power, bio fuels Solar PV' and Wind for
local and exports
Source: www.brics.tpprf.ru/download.php?GET=6LPAY%2F81Bmw4jugd58EVrg%3D%3D
Figure 18. Table 3 :
3
Brazil Russia India China South Africa
No data Renova Group who Lanco Energy, Moserbaer Renova SAREC The South African Rene-
available. were involved in India, Kiran Energy, Tata Group who wable Energy Council was an
developing renewable Power Solar, Welspun were involved umbrella body to co ordinate and
energy in India and Energy, ACME Solar, IL&FS in developing align the activities of its
South Africa Energy, Thermax India, renewable stakeholders in the renewable
Mahindra Partners, energy in Ind- sector. A need had been identi-
Sunbourne Energy, Waaree ia and South fied for manufacturing facilities to
Energy, sRRB Ener-gy, Africa setup in South Africa for Solar
Clique energy, Suzlon India, PV's and Wind for local and
wind world India, Global exports
wind Power, Gamesa Wind
turbines, Green Infra, Inox
wind, NEPC India, Sindica-
tum Sustainable Resou-
rces, Yashwant Energy,
Organic Recycling System
and Grow diesel Ventures
Source: www.brics.tpprf.ru/download.php?GET=6LPAY%2F81Bmw4jugd58EVrg%3D%3D
Technology transfer and high technology India
Parternerships in the energy and green economy industry with the other BRICS countries India had joint ventures /investment in Process Technology Parternerships in:
Brazil i. PV manufacturing and wind turbine supply
Brazil had 40 years of experience in developing ii.
the largest ethanol programme in the world to substitute
fossil fuels.
Russia
a. Russia established a working group bringing
together investors, international organizations and
multilateral development banks and the OECD to
develop a dialogue on actions needed to foster
financing for green and low carbon intensive
technologies in BRICS countries.
b. Russia had a number of solutions on solar energy
project development for India and South Africa.
Figure 19.
South Africa in South Africa to generate 1200 MW of through a
South Africa renewable energy companies pump storage scheme.
wanted to pursue with other BRICS countries as well as 4. Batoka Gorge hydro power -hydro electric plant
South African government on the following projects with capacity of 1600 MW in Zambia and Zambezi
1. Expansion of Inga and Grand Inga on the river of Basin.
hydropower station in DRC and associated Source: brics.tpprf.ru/download.php?GET=6LPAY%2F81Bm-
transmission infrastrure. w4jugd58EVrg%3D%3D
2. Mphanda Nkuwa construction of a 1500 MW hydro
power station in Mozambique and Zambezi Basin.
3. Lesotho highlands water project phase 2 -water
transfer programme to supply to Gauteng province
Figure 20. Table 4 :
4
Sr no BRIC country Brazil Russia India China South Africa
01 Climate change target 43% 25 to 30% 30-35 % Reducing Reducing carbon
emissions cut reduction increase in carbon emissions to 398-
by 2030 by 2030 carbon emissions by 614 Mtoe
relative to relative to emissions 60 to 65%
2005 1990 by 2030 relative to
2005
02 CO2 emissions compared to +113% -33%S +238% +332% +144%
1990
03 Annual CO2 emissions per capita 9.1 tons 15.75 tons 2.33 tons 7.91 tons 8.8 tons (2012)
(2012) (2012) (2012) (2012)
04 Share of renewable power in 75 % 16% 16% 22% 02%
2014
Source: www.greenpeace.de
Key findings
1. China has set very ambitious target of reducing
carbon emissions by 60 to 65% relative to 2005.
Brazil is already into renewable energy and has a
moderate target 43% emission cut by 2030 relative
to 2005.Surprisingly Russia has set low target of
reducing carbon emissions.
2. CO2 emissions compared to 1990 China has
maximum CO2emissions compared to 1990(+332)
followed by India (+238%).AS both are populist
countries and amount to almost one-third of the
world's population.
3. India has least CO2 emissions per capita whereas
has Russia maximumCO2 emissions per capita.
This may be due to about 65% of population live in
villages and usage of vehicles is less due to poor
infrastructure and affordability. Russia maximum
CO2 emissions per capita as the country are mainly
into nuclear plants and space applications.
4. Brazil has tapped natural resources and share of
renewable power in 2014 is maximum whereas
South Africa has last used the natural resources
amounting least Share of renewable power in 2014
IV.
1
2

Appendix A

  1. Comparative study of BRICS countries on Renewable Energy,
  2. Develop clean energy and save energy or perish. Dr , Kurtkoti , Ashok . Allana Management Journal of Research July-December2011. p. .
  3. State's renewable energy potential is 2.13 lakh MW. World Institute of Sustainable Energy Report Identifies The Policy And Framework, The Times of India, M Damle . 2010. May 19. Pune. p. 4.
  4. Mea , Gov . www.brics.mid.ru/bdomp/brics.nsf/Ufa_partnershipstrategy_eng.pdf bilateral-documents.com.htm? dtl/26045 /Joint---on-IndiaBrazil----,retrieved on, p. .
  5. Powering India. S Bana . Business India 2009. Aug. 09. p. .
  6. Six Million Indians do not have electricity. Business India 2009. Feb 08. p. .
Notes
1
© 2016 Global Journals Inc. (US)
2
Source: www.greenpeace.de © 2016 Global Journals Inc. (US)
Date: 2016-01-15