Migration Flows in Brazil: A Spatial Analysis using Tobler´S Approach

Table of contents

1. Introduction

razil finds itself in an advanced phase of the process of demographic transition. The shrinking of the base of the aging pyramid and the growth of its vertex are already noticeable. This essay intends to compare the migration flow figures of two distinct periods: 1995/200 and 2005/2010, in order to ascertain what kind of migration flows is occurring in this period, that could eventually explain some of its migration behavior.(Figures 1-7)

A new phenomena that concern these migratory fluctuations has been taken to note and has been the studies of various research projects in the academic environment: a decline in net migration rate from traditionally underdeveloped regions (mainly the northeast) to more industrialized regions (primarily the southeast).

This decline in the net migration rate can be partly explained by return migration. Considering that fact, it is of fundamental importance to know migratory patterns of the population so as to foresee the spatial redistribution of the population in general that will eventually result in the reformulation of social policy to better regionally allocate national resources.

Spatial analysis and GIS are widely used in order to study such events (Bailey and Gatrell, 1996). Specifically in this case, Tobler's approach is used (Tobler, 1976) for mapping the flows and, for the identification of migration patterns.

2. II.

3. Tobler's Approach

If a potential migrant is taken at random in a population sample and is "thrown in the air", there will be a general migration tendency that this person will follow. Tobler calls this tendency a "wind" (Tobler, 1976). He has focused on the difficulties associated with the symmetry of the gravity model and tried to remove this problem introducing the "wind" in order to account for interaction in particular directions. The approach facilitates the description of large flow matrices by analyzing the asymmetric part of the from-to-tables.

It is interesting to see that the antecedents of the approach were motivated by the calculation of geographical locations from data on separations or on interaction. The inversion of models was used: for example, the social gravity model can be written as:

4. And the inversion is

The problem was that the social gravity model is symmetric, i. e, D ij = D ji and M ij must be equal to M ij . In practice the data are different (M ij ? M ji ). This would imply that if the model is inverted, D ij ? D ji .

He stated that has "the consequence that the tri-lateration solution can result in more than one geometrical configuration or that the standard errors of the position determination are increased" (Tobler, 1976. p. 2).

To overcome this problem, a "wind" was introduced in order to facilitate interaction in some direction. This vector is estimated by the data. In its formal aspect, each location i, with coordinates (x, y), has associated with a vector with magnitude and direction:

5. B

Volume XXI Issue III Version I

( ) ij j i ij D f P P K M . . = ? ? ? ? ? ? ? ? = ? j i ij ij P KP M f D 1 ( )( ) [ ] ? = = ? ? + ? ? = n j i i j i j ij ji ij ji ij y x x x D m m m m n i 1 1 . 1 . 1 1 ?

6. Where

. For the complete algebraic development, see Tobler (1979).

( ) ( ) 2 2 2 i j i j ij y y x x D ? + ? =

Sometimes we have an incomplete matrix for a set of data, so in order to overcome this situation a complete set of data is generated, using Baxter entropy program (Tobler, 1976). The program follows Wilson's derivations of the gravity model using entropymaximizing techniques. It has three variations and one can use a complete matrix or only the marginals as input. The program permits two variations with the gravity model or with the entropy model.

In the research described here we have used a

7. Results

In the comparison of the data migration between the periods of 1995/2000 and 2005/2010 for the Northern region, the States of Rondônia, Amazonas, Roraima, Amapá and Tocantins continued to receive immigrants, showing a positive balance for both periods, with the exception of the States of Acre and Pará that continued to show a negative balance, but with a significant decrease in the number of emigrants in the comparison between the two periods considered.

In the Northeast region it was observed a quite expressive negative balance for almost all States, especially for the States of Bahia and Maranhão, who contributed with significant numbers of emigrants by repeating the tendency observed in the 1995/2000 period, without major modifications. The States of Piauí, Ceará and Alagoas kept negative figures, but decreased their numbers in absolute values for both periods, perhaps showing some modification in their migratory pattern, which should be better measured in the future. Only the States of Sergipe and Rio Grande do Norte presented a positive migratory balance, perhaps due to new investments in the tourism sector, typical of these States.

In the Southeast region the negative highlights went to the State of Minas Gerais, which was the only one to make a considerable change in its demographic profile presenting, in the 1995/2000 period, an expressive number of immigrants, but in the period 2005/2010 presented a negative number in its migratory balance. The State of Espírito Santo showed a significant increase of immigrants, nearly doubling its values of the previous decade, probably due to the new investments in oil extraction and in agribusiness. The States of Rio de Janeiro and São Paulo also presented a positive migratory balance, but with much smaller values than the previous decade, perhaps explained by the so called return migration, which has been shown to be significant in Brazil in the past two decades.

In the Southern region the Santa Catarina State occupies a prominent position showing an expressive positive migratory balance, almost tripling the number of immigrants in the last decade. The States of Paraná and Rio Grande do Sul have maintained the tendency of negative balances in the last two decades, but the State of Rio Grande do Sul, presented an even more expressive negative balance for the last evaluated period.

All This decrease is also well perceived in interregional migration. According to the 2000 Census, 3.3 million people had changed regions in the five previous years. The national survey samples (PNAD) of 2004 already shows a reduction to 2.8 million. Finally, the National Household Survey of 2009 shows that just over 2 million people had chosen another region to live.

In the South, the States of Paraná and Rio Grande do Sul perceived a considerable flow of return migration, while Santa Catarina is the southern State that attracts more new immigrants -its current migratory balance is 80 thousand immigrants. The same process can be observed in the Midwestern region, being the region that more retains its immigrants. According to the 2009 PNAD, in absolute terms, São Paulo remains as the State that receives more immigrants (535.000), followed by Minas Gerais (288.000), Goiás (264.000) Bahia and Paraná (both with 203.000 new immigrants). On the other hand, São Paulo is also the place that Migration Flows in Brazil: A Spatial Analysis using Tobler´S Approach generates more emigrants (588.000), followed by Bahia (312.000), Minas Gerais (276.000), Paraná (171.000) and Rio de Janeiro (165.000). (Figures 1-3).

8. Tables and Maps

Figure 1.
Author ?: Ph.D, (PUCMINAS-BRAZIL). e-mail: jofabreu@hotmail.com Author ?: (PUCMINAS-BRAZIL) Author ?: MSc. (Ph.D, Student)
Figure 2.
States of the Midwest region showed a positive balance regarding migration, especially the State of Goiás which presented an expressive number of immigrants for both periods. The State of Mato Grosso do Sul showed a profound modification in its migratory pattern, showing a positive balance for the period 2005/2010 compared to a negative number for the period 1995/2000. The States of Mato Grosso and the Federal District (Distrito Federal) both showed positive balances but with much lower immigration values for the period between 2005/2010. The number of Brazilians who have changed their State of residence is decreasing for the past 15 years, according to data from the Brazilian Institute of Geography and Statistics (IBGE). The survey shows that, between 1995 and 2000, about 5.2 million people have changed the State of residence. Between 2000 and 2004, the number went down to 4.6 million. The latest data indicates that between 2004 and 2009, just over 3.2 million people moved from their State of residence -there is an important decrease of 37% in the comparison between 2000 and 2009 data.
Figure 3.
III.
Figure 4. Table 1
1
1995/2000 2005/2010
Federation Units
Immigrants Emigrants Net Migration Immigrants Emigrants Net Migration
BRASIL 5 196 093 5 196 093 0 4 643 754 '4 643 754 0
Rondônia 83 325 72 735 10 590 65 864 53 643 12 221
Acre 13 634 16 070 -2 436 13 882 14 746 -865
Amazonas 89 627 58 657 30 970 71 451 51 301 20 150
Roraima 47 752 14 379 33 373 25 556 11 204 14 352
Pará 182 043 234 239 -52 195 162 004 201 834 -39 830
Amapá 44 582 15 113 29 469 37 028 15 228 21 800
Tocantins 95 430 82 515 12 915 85 706 77 052 8 654
Maranhão 100 816 274 469 -173 653 105 684 270 664 -164 980
Piauí 88 740 140 815 -52 075 73 614 144 037 -70 423
Ceará 162 925 186 710 -23 785 112 373 181 221 -68 849
Rio G. do Norte 77 916 71 287 6 630 67 728 54 017 13 711
Paraíba 102 005 163 485 -61 480 96 028 125 521 -29 493
Pernambuco 164 871 280 290 -115 419 148 498 223 584 -75 086
Alagoas 55 966 127 948 -71 982 53 589 130 306 -76 717
Sergipe 52 111 56 928 -4 817 53 039 45 144 7 895
Bahia 250 571 518 036 -267 465 229 224 466 360 -237 136
Minas Gerais 447 782 408 658 39 124 376 520 390 625 -14 105
Espírito Santo 129 169 95 168 34 001 130 820 70 120 60 700
Rio de Janeiro 319 749 274 213 45 536 270 413 247 309 23 104
São Paulo 1 223 811 883 885 339 926 991 314 735 519 255 796
Paraná 297 311 336 998 -39 687 272 184 293 693 -21 509
Santa Catarina 199 653 139 667 59 986 301 341 128 888 172 453
Rio G. do Sul 113 395 152 890 -39 495 102 613 177 263 -74 650
Mato G. do Sul 97 709 108 738 -11 029 98 973 80 908 18 065
Mato Grosso 166 299 123 724 42 575 143 954 121 589 22 365
Goiás 372 702 169 900 202 802 363 934 156 107 207 827
Distrito Federal 216 200 188 577 27 623 190 422
1

Appendix A

  1. 91): "The Elderly Mobility Transition in Brazil, An Exploratory Analysis, C C Machado , J F Abreu . (Paper presented at Elderly Mobility Transition Seminar -Aspen Colorado)
  2. International and National Migratory Movements. G Beijer . International Migration VIII 1970. (3) p. .
  3. An Economic Analysis of Internal Migration in Brazil. Gian S Sahota . Journal of Political Economy 1968. Mar. -Apr., 1968. 76 (2) p. .
  4. O tamanho da população brasileira e sua distribuição etária: uma visão prospectiva. J A M Carvalho . VI Encontro Nacional de Estudos Populacionais, 88 p. . (Recife)
  5. Migration and Money Flows in Brazil. A Spatial Analysis, J Abreu . Ann Arbor, Michigan: U. of Mi. Press.
  6. , J Abreu , L C Barroso , Geografia . 2003. Belo Horizonte: PUC Minas. (Modelo de Análise Espacial e GIS)
  7. Desigualdades Econômicas e Sociais: Aplicacões Computacionais. J Abreu , R Mingucci , A Muzzarelli . PUCMINAS 2018.
  8. Gravity with gravitas: a solution to the border puzzle. J E Anderson , E Van Wincoop . Am Econ -Rev 2003. 93 (1) p. .
  9. , J F Abreu , A Muzzarelli . Introduzione ai Sistemi Informativi Geografici. Franco Angeli (ed.) 2003. Forum Católica de Minas Gerais, Milano, Italy.
  10. Kam Chan , Li Wing , Zhang . The Hukou system and rural-urban migration: processes and changes. The China Quarterly, 1999. p. .
  11. Remapping China's regional disparities, 19902006: A New Assessment of de facto and de jure Population Data. Kam Chan , Man Wing , Wang . Eurasian Geography and Economics 2008. 49 (1) p. .
  12. Potential migration from Central and Eastern Europe into the EU-15-an update, P Alvarez-Plata , H Brucker , B Siliverstovs . 2003. DG Employment and Social Affairs. (Report) (for the European Commission)
  13. The Age of Migration. S Castles , M J Miller . Houndmills 2009. MacMillan Press Ltd.
  14. Interactive Spatial Data Analysis, T Bailey , A Gatrell . N. Y.: W. S. Press.
  15. Spatial Interaction Patterns. W Tobler . Journal of Environment Systems 6 (76) p. .
  16. W Tobler . Estimation of Attractivities from Interactions, 11 p. .
Notes
1
© 2021 Global JournalsMigration Flows in Brazil: A Spatial Analysis using Tobler´S Approach
Date: 2021-05-15